What is Simple Trial Procedure in Criminal Procedure?

Simple trial procedure is a special procedure that ensures a fast and practical trial process for certain crimes in criminal procedure. This procedure aims to speed up the trial process, reduce the workload of the courts and to conclude the trials in a shorter time. The simple trial procedure, regulated in Article 251 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, can be applied if certain conditions are met.

1. What is the Purpose of Simple Trial Procedure?
Acceleration of Trial: The most basic purpose of simple trial procedure is to provide a faster trial process for certain crimes. This reduces the workload of the courts and contributes to the conclusion of cases in a short time.
Providing Material and Spiritual Savings: Shortening the trial process saves the parties time and money. Courts are also relieved of unnecessary trial processes.

2. In Which Crimes Can It Be Applied?

Simple trial procedure can only be applied for certain crimes. According to the Code of Criminal Procedure, crimes that require a prison sentence of two years or less or a judicial fine are subject to this procedure.

Sample Crimes:

Insult (TCK Art. 125),
Damage to property (TCK Art. 151),
Threat (TCK Art. 106/1),
Less punishments for the crime of theft (TCK Art. 142).

3. How Does the Simple Trial Procedure Work?
Preparation and Notification of the Indictment: The simple trial procedure begins with the prosecutor preparing the indictment and notifying the defendant and other parties of this indictment. During this process, the court may make a decision on the file without holding a hearing.
The Defendant Makes a Defense: Upon notification of the indictment to the defendant, the defendant may make a written defense within the period granted to him/her. The defendant may make a written statement through his/her lawyer or directly during this process.
Decision Making: The court may review the defendant’s defense and the scope of the file and make a decision without holding a hearing. In this decision, the court may impose a penalty or issue an acquittal decision if the elements of the crime have occurred.

Right to Object: Decisions made with the simple trial procedure are not final for the defendant and other parties. If no objection is made within 7 days after the decision is notified, the decision becomes final. However, if one of the parties objects, the normal trial procedure is passed and the trial continues with a hearing.

4. Results of the Simple Trial Procedure
Reduction in Sentence: In trials conducted with the simple trial procedure, the court may apply a 25% discount when giving a sentence. This discount provides a significant advantage in favor of the defendant. Example: If a person is sentenced to 1 year in prison for the crime of damaging property, this sentence can be reduced to 9 months with a 25% discount with the simple trial procedure.

Shortening of the Trial Process: Since no hearing is held, the trial process is considerably shortened. Courts generally reach quick results by making decisions based on documents.

5. Situations Where the Simple Trial Procedure Will Not Be Applied

In some cases, the simple trial procedure cannot be applied. These include;

The defendant is under 18 years of age,
The crime is a crime that requires a prison sentence of more than 2 years,
The crime requires a comprehensive investigation.

6. Sample Application

A citizen is complained about for insulting his neighbor. The prosecutor’s office prepares an indictment for the crime of insult and submits it to the court. Since the crime of insult is a crime that requires a sentence of 2 years or less, the simple trial procedure is applied. After the defendant presents his written defense, the court reduces the 1-year prison sentence to 9 months by applying a 25% discount to the defendant. Since the parties do not object, the decision becomes final.

7. Differences Between Simple Trial Procedure and Normal Trial
No Hearing: In simple trial procedure, no hearing is held; the decision is given based on the file. In normal trial, a hearing is held and witnesses can be heard.
Quick Decision Making: In simple trial procedure, the decision is given faster. Normal trial may require a longer process.
Reduction in Sentence: While a 25% penalty reduction is applied in simple trial procedure, such a reduction is not made in normal trial.