What is the Maximum Length of Detention?

The duration of detention is one of the important issues of law and is carefully regulated in terms of both freedom and justice. In Turkey, the duration of detention is limited by the Constitution and the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK). Here is what you need to know about this subject:

1. What is Detention?

An arrest is the temporary restriction of the freedom of a suspect or defendant due to the risk of escape or obscuring evidence during a criminal investigation or prosecution. The decision of detention is made by a judge and is a precautionary measure.

2. Limits of Detention Periods

The CMK has set clear limits on detention periods. These limits vary according to the nature of the crime and the amount of the penalty:

For crimes that are not within the jurisdiction of the high criminal court:
Maximum detention period: 1 year.
However, in cases of necessity, this period can be extended by a maximum of 6 months. A total of 1 year and 6 months of detention can be spent.
For crimes falling within the jurisdiction of the high criminal court:
Maximum detention period: 2 years.
In cases of necessity, this period can be extended for another 3 years. Thus, a total of 5 years of detention can be applied.

3. Detention Period for Children

Detention periods are shorter for those under the age of 18. Within the framework of the Child Protection Law:

Detention period for children: Maximum 1 year, but this period can be extended for another 1 year for serious crimes.

4. States of Emergency and Exceptional Cases

There may be some exceptions to detention periods during states of emergency or for terrorist crimes. For example:

Terrorist crimes: Detention periods may be longer for these crimes falling within the jurisdiction of the high criminal court. However, it should not be forgotten that these periods are reviewed by the Constitutional Court and kept under control within the scope of the right to individual application.

5. Judicial Control Option

Instead of an arrest warrant, courts may also apply judicial control measures on the suspect or defendant. Under judicial control, the person is subject to certain obligations, but does not have to stay in prison. This option is often preferred, especially in cases where the detention period is extended.

6. European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and Detention Period

Since Turkey is a party to the European Convention on Human Rights, long detention periods are also monitored by the ECtHR. Due to the right to a trial within a reasonable time, unnecessary extension of the detention period may be considered contrary to the ECHR.

7. Case Studies and Decisions
Balyoz and Ergenekon Cases: The long detention of the defendants in these cases has led to discussions on detention periods in Turkey. The defendants applied to the ECtHR and it was decided that the right to a trial within a reasonable time was violated.
Deniz Feneri Case: In this case, the defendants were released by benefiting from judicial control provisions due to their long detention periods, thus drawing attention to the limitations on detention periods.
8.

Detention periods are an important balancing element in the legal system. It is of great importance that these periods are not exceeded in terms of protecting the right to liberty of the individual. Courts may extend the detention period or apply measures such as judicial control depending on the characteristics of each case. However, these processes must comply with national and international legal rules.