In contested divorce cases, the judge tries to understand whether the marriage union has been shaken to its core while evaluating the parties’ claims and defenses. When making his decision, he pays attention to the evidence presented within the framework of the law and the concrete circumstances of the incident. Here are the important points that the judge pays attention to in contested divorce:

1. Fault

The judge tries to understand which of the parties damaged the marriage union more and who is at fault. During this process:

Infidelity (adultery),
Physical or psychological violence,
Economic irresponsibility,
Infidelity,
Failure to fulfill marital obligations are evaluated.

2. Legality of Evidence

The judge examines whether the evidence presented has been obtained in accordance with the law. For example:

Evidence such as messages, photographs, witness statements,
Audio or video recordings must be obtained within legal limits. Otherwise, this evidence may be considered invalid.
3. Witness Statements

The statements of the witnesses presented by the parties have an important place in the judge’s evaluation. The impartiality of the witnesses and their clear narration of the events may affect the course of the case.

4. Status of the Children (If Any)

If the couple has children in common, the judge will make a careful assessment of their custody. In this assessment, factors such as:

The best interests of the child,
The living conditions of the mother and father,
The ability to meet the child’s psychological and physical needs,
The child’s age and his/her own opinion are taken into consideration.

5. Division of Property and Financial Claims

When examining the division of the property acquired by the parties during the marriage and the alimony requests, the judge will take into consideration:

The economic situation of the spouses,
Their contributions to the marriage union,
Past economic neglects or injustices.
6. Fundamental Disruption of the Marriage Union

According to the Turkish Civil Code, in order for a divorce to take place, it must be proven that the marriage union has been fundamentally disrupted. The judge evaluates the claims of the parties and tries to determine:

Whether it is possible for the parties to live together,
Whether the continuation of the marriage has become unbearable for both parties.

7. Possibility of Agreement

In contentious cases, the judge may also consider the possibility of the parties reaching an agreement through mediation and may suggest the parties in this direction.

8. Justification of Requests

It is important for the parties to justify their divorce, alimony, compensation and other requests with concrete events. The judge evaluates whether the justifications on which the requests are based are reasonable.

:

The judge examines the parties’ statements and evidence in detail and tries to determine who is at fault in legal and moral terms. The best interests of the children, economic balance and legal evidence are among the most important elements that the judge pays attention to. You can manage the litigation process more effectively by getting support from a lawyer.